Search Glossary
Dictionary of Terms
Bridging the Divide: Strategic Gap Assessments
Explore how effective gap assessments identify discrepancies between current and desired states, enabling prioritized improvement planning and efficient resource allocation.
What is a Gap Assessment?
A Gap Assessment is a systematic process of comparing an organization's current state against a desired future state, standard, or regulatory requirement to identify differences or "gaps." This analytical tool provides a clear picture of where an organization stands relative to where it needs or wants to be.
In the context of management systems, a Gap Assessment evaluates existing processes, policies, procedures, and practices against specific standards or regulations to identify areas of non-compliance or opportunities for improvement. Unlike audits, which focus primarily on conformance to requirements, Gap Assessments are more strategic and forward-looking, serving as a foundation for improvement planning and prioritization.
Why Gap Assessment Matters
For organizations in highly regulated and high-consequence industries such as pipeline operations, oil & gas, and energy, Gap Assessments provide critical insights that drive compliance and performance improvement. Gap Assessment matters because:
It Establishes a Baseline: Gap Assessments provide a clear understanding of current capabilities as a starting point for improvement.
It Prioritizes Efforts: By identifying the most significant gaps, organizations can focus resources where they'll have the greatest impact.
It Reduces Compliance Risk: Proactive identification of gaps allows organizations to address non-compliances before they result in regulatory findings or incidents.
It Supports Strategic Planning: Understanding gaps informs the development of realistic implementation plans and timelines.
How Gap Assessment Works in Practice
When Applied4Sight consultants conduct Gap Assessments, we typically follow these key steps:
Defining the Standard: We clearly establish the requirements, standards, or expectations that will serve as the basis for comparison.
Current State Analysis: We gather evidence through document reviews, interviews, observations, and other methods to understand existing processes and practices.
Gap Identification: We systematically compare current state against the standard to identify gaps and determine their significance.
Root Cause Analysis: We analyze the underlying causes of significant gaps to inform effective solutions.
Gap Closure Planning: We develop practical, prioritized plans to address identified gaps and move toward the desired state.
Regulatory Context for Gap Assessment
While Gap Assessment itself isn't explicitly required by most regulations, it's an essential tool for achieving compliance:
Regulation/Agency | Relationship to Gap Assessment |
|---|---|
CER (Canada) | Gap Assessment supports compliance with management system requirements in the OPR |
PHMSA (US) | Gap Assessment helps identify compliance issues with pipeline safety regulations |
API RP 1173 | Gap Assessment serves as a starting point for PSMS implementation |
ISO Standards | Gap Assessment is a common approach to preparing for ISO certification |
Best Practices for Gap Assessment
Based on our extensive experience conducting Gap Assessments across multiple industries, Applied4Sight recommends the following best practices:
Comprehensive Scope: Ensure the assessment covers all relevant requirements, not just those that seem most challenging.
Evidence-Based Approach: Base gap determinations on objective evidence rather than assumptions or intentions.
Significance Rating: Develop a consistent methodology for rating the significance of gaps to support prioritization.
Root Cause Focus: Look beyond immediate gaps to understand underlying causes that may affect multiple areas.